Comments on: Instant Replay System In Major League Baseball Fails Test http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/ Wed, 01 Feb 2012 14:31:20 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0 By: Bloggination Domination | Zoner Sports http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-262 Bloggination Domination | Zoner Sports Wed, 13 May 2009 13:23:14 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-262 [...] MLB Instant Replay Already Fails Paneech [...] [...] MLB Instant Replay Already Fails Paneech [...]

]]> By: InGameNow » Monday Munchies: Your 4/20 Linkage http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-159 InGameNow » Monday Munchies: Your 4/20 Linkage Tue, 21 Apr 2009 00:00:38 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-159 [...] Instant Replay System In Major League Baseball Fails Test [Paneech.com] [...] [...] Instant Replay System In Major League Baseball Fails Test [Paneech.com] [...]

]]> By: 4-20-09 Sports Blog Bucks Links! | Sports Blog Bucks http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-158 4-20-09 Sports Blog Bucks Links! | Sports Blog Bucks Mon, 20 Apr 2009 20:50:14 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-158 [...] MLB Instant replay FAIL < Paneech [...] [...] MLB Instant replay FAIL < Paneech [...]

]]> By: NESW Sports Headlines 4-20-2009 | NESW Sports, Sports Videos http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-157 NESW Sports Headlines 4-20-2009 | NESW Sports, Sports Videos Mon, 20 Apr 2009 20:46:48 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-157 [...] MLB Instant replay FAIL < Paneech [...] [...] MLB Instant replay FAIL < Paneech [...]

]]> By: Fan Gives A Little Hand With Jorge Posada’s Home Run Ball http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-156 Fan Gives A Little Hand With Jorge Posada’s Home Run Ball Mon, 20 Apr 2009 14:41:00 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-156 [...] only problem is that after looking at the replay of the home run, we have concluded that the home run hit by Jorge Posada was an error.  The correct call should [...] [...] only problem is that after looking at the replay of the home run, we have concluded that the home run hit by Jorge Posada was an error.  The correct call should [...]

]]> By: TJ http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-155 TJ Mon, 20 Apr 2009 13:58:58 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-155 STO only shows the angle they want you to see other angles show the ball cleared the wall before contact was made. STO only shows the angle they want you to see other angles show the ball cleared the wall before contact was made.

]]> By: Jonathan http://paneech.com/2009/04/instant-replay-system-in-major-league-baseball-fails-test/#comment-153 Jonathan Mon, 20 Apr 2009 04:40:16 +0000 http://paneech.com/?p=207#comment-153 It's hard to tell. That first replay is very misleading though, the wall is much thicker than it looks. One of the later replays shows just how thick it is. So just because you see them over the top of the wall, doesn't mean they are over the field of play. Crowe's glove was definitely over the top of the wall when he was coming down (it clearly hits the top), but I don't know where he was when they made contact. It’s hard to tell.

That first replay is very misleading though, the wall is much thicker than it looks. One of the later replays shows just how thick it is. So just because you see them over the top of the wall, doesn’t mean they are over the field of play.

Crowe’s glove was definitely over the top of the wall when he was coming down (it clearly hits the top), but I don’t know where he was when they made contact.

]]>