There was not too much to brag about if you followed the Youngstown State Lady Penguins.  Only dressing seven girls for most of the season, minutes were piled on starters and fatigue naturally took its toll on human bodies.  The result was a nightmare of a season, a winless campaign.  One ray of hope was Brandi Brown, the true Freshman from California who posted double-doubles almost every other game.

Brandi Brown was bypassed in the Horizon League awards for Newcomer of The Year honors.  This recognition went to Yar Shayok of Detroit, who just played at Youngstown State last week and had a good game.  This editorial is, by no means, intended to downplay Shayok’s recognition as a great future player for Detroit, but rather to question why she received the award instead of YSU’s Brown.

Brown was the leader in the entire conference in rebounding with a 10.8 RPG average.  THE ENTIRE CONFERENCE, not just the Freshmen.  Shouldn’t that merit her an award to first or second team all-Horizon League?  Dennis Rodman never averaged more than ten points a game in any season, yet was named to the NBA’s All-Star team several times because of his rebounding and defensive presence.  Brandi Brown is not Dennis Rodman, don’t take that analogy out of context, she is actually good on both ends of the floor.

Brown also led all Freshman in scoring with 11.6 points per game.  So she was the leader of the Freshman scoring race, and the Horizon League leader in rebounds and does not garner this award?  Did Yar Shayok play the immunity idol here? 

I am not sure what more the Horizon League wanted Brown to do to prove she was the best Freshman in the league.  Was this a political choice?  Because Detroit played well enough to win some games, the award is defaulted to a Freshman on the team with the best record?

If the choice was made because Youngstown State did not win a game, then the league should consider changing the name of the award to “Best Freshman on A Winning Team with The Best Supporting Cast”.

What made Brandi Brown’s year even more special is that when she got three fouls, she was forced to ease up and play cautiously.  How did she manage to put all of those numbers up playing hurt, tired, and sometimes in foul trouble?

Boo Horizon League.  I don’t care if Youngstown State won a game or not.  This is not a team award, it is an individual accolade, and you robbed the true Newcomer of The Year based on the statistics.  Leading rebounder in the league, top Freshman scorer, obstacle central with no depth, and you managed to keep Youngstown State down, yet again.

No Responses to “Brandi Brown Robbed For Horizon League Newcomer Of The Year Award”